By Stephen Morley, President of the Confederation of British Metalforming (CBM)
There has rarely been a more important time for British businesses to have a strong collective voice. Government ineptitude, growing international trade tensions and an increasingly uncertain economic environment are exposing just how vulnerable UK businesses, particularly SMEs, can be when political decisions are made without a proper understanding of their commercial consequences.
For me, one thing is becoming increasingly clear: the role of trade associations has never been more important. And, perhaps more significantly, neither has the role of specialist, sector-specific trade associations that understand the industries they represent.
We are living through a period of significant industrial and economic change. Governments are talking about reindustrialisation, economic growth, productivity, skills and strengthening domestic supply chains. Yet, at the same time, businesses are facing rising operating costs, uncompetitive energy prices, increasing employment costs, regulatory burdens and the consequences of trade disputes over which they have little or no control.
The disconnect between political ambition and the reality of running a business has become difficult to ignore.
And it is often the smallest businesses that pay the highest price.
The SME voice is easily overlooked
Large corporations have the resources to employ government relations teams, professional lobbyists and economic advisers. They can secure meetings with ministers, commission research and make their case directly to those in positions of influence.
The majority of British businesses cannot.
For an SME, the managing director is often also the sales director, finance director and the person responsible for keeping production moving. There simply isn’t the time, resource or expertise to monitor every government consultation, understand every legislative change or challenge every policy that threatens their competitiveness.
I have often described SMEs as “Small Mistreated Entities”. It is a deliberately provocative play on the familiar acronym, but there is a serious point behind it.
Too often, smaller businesses appear to be an afterthought in government policy. They are expected to absorb rising costs, navigate increasingly complex regulation, invest in new technologies, meet changing employment requirements and compete internationally, often without the resources or support available to larger organisations.
They are regularly told that they are the backbone of the economy, yet too frequently treated as though they are peripheral to the decisions that shape it.
This is where trade associations come into their own.
They provide a collective voice for businesses that would otherwise struggle to be heard. They understand the sectors they represent, bring together commercial experience and translate the day-to-day challenges facing members into evidence and arguments that policymakers can understand.
Importantly, they can also identify the unintended consequences of government policy before those consequences become irreversible.
That is not simply lobbying. It is an essential part of ensuring that government understands the industries it is trying to support.
Why specialist trade associations matter
Not all trade associations are the same, and it is important that government recognises the distinction.
Larger, cross-sector business organisations undoubtedly have an important role in representing the wider business community. However, the breadth of their membership inevitably means that they must balance the interests of many different industries, sometimes with very different priorities.
Specialist trade associations offer something different.
At the Confederation of British Metalforming (CBM), our membership is concentrated within a clearly defined industrial sector. We represent businesses involved in metalforming and its associated manufacturing supply chains, bringing together companies that share many of the same technical, commercial and regulatory challenges.
That focus is one of our greatest strengths.
Although CBM is a specialist organisation, the scale of the industry we represent is considerable. Our membership collectively accounts for approximately £27 billion in turnover and supports more than 70,000 employees.
Those figures demonstrate why specialist associations should never be judged simply by the number of companies on their membership lists.
CBM represents a substantial and strategically important part of British manufacturing, supplying industries including automotive, aerospace, construction and engineering.
Approximately 85% of our membership comprises SMEs. However, we also have Tier 1 suppliers and major corporate members, including JLR and NatWest.
This combination is particularly valuable. It brings together smaller manufacturers, major suppliers, customers and organisations supporting the wider industrial sector.
It also means that CBM can understand and represent the challenges facing businesses at different levels of the supply chain, while recognising the commercial relationships and dependencies between them.
When we speak to government, we are not simply presenting the views of an isolated group of companies. We are drawing upon the collective experience of businesses operating throughout a highly interconnected manufacturing sector.
That gives our voice both credibility and authority.
The forgotten link in the supply chain
One of the recurring frustrations in British industrial policy is the tendency to concentrate on the biggest names and the most visible parts of an industry.
Whether it is steel, automotive, aerospace, construction or engineering, the headlines tend to focus on the major manufacturers, the primary producers and the large investment announcements.
But what about the thousands of businesses supplying them?
These are often the second, third and fourth-tier suppliers, the specialist manufacturers, component producers, distributors and processors that provide the foundations on which much of British industry depends.
They are frequently the forgotten link in the supply chain.
The danger is that policies designed to support one part of an industry can inadvertently undermine another. Protecting a domestic producer, for example, might create additional costs for a downstream manufacturer. Supporting a major automotive company does not necessarily mean that the benefits reach the smaller businesses supplying its components.
This is not an argument against supporting our major industries. Quite the opposite. It is an argument for recognising that their success depends on the strength and competitiveness of the entire supply chain.
This is precisely where specialist trade associations have a particularly important role.
Because CBM represents businesses operating within the same industrial ecosystem, we can identify how decisions affecting one part of the supply chain may impact another.
Our relationships with SMEs, Tier 1 suppliers and major corporate members provide valuable insight into these interdependencies.
It is this detailed understanding that enables specialist associations to challenge policies that might appear sensible at a national level but create serious unintended consequences for the businesses expected to operate under them.
When trade becomes a political weapon
The return of protectionism and the growing use of tariffs as political and economic weapons have added another layer of uncertainty.
The United States, the European Union and China are increasingly pursuing industrial strategies designed to protect their own economies, secure supply chains and strengthen domestic manufacturing.
For British manufacturers, these developments are not distant geopolitical arguments. They affect the cost of raw materials, access to markets, investment decisions and the competitiveness of their products.
Steel and aluminium tariffs, safeguarding measures, rules of origin, carbon border taxes and the growing emphasis on domestic content are all examples of how quickly the trading environment can change.
The challenge for the UK is that we cannot afford to sit between competing industrial strategies without having a clear understanding of where we fit.
The European Union’s emerging Industrial Accelerator Act and its ‘Made in Europe’ ambitions are a case in point. As our European neighbours look to strengthen their own manufacturing supply chains, UK businesses risk being excluded from opportunities that they have historically been part of.
CBM has argued consistently that a closer practical relationship with Europe is essential if British manufacturers are not to become the forgotten link in Europe’s new industrial strategy.
This is not about reopening the debate on rejoining the EU. It is about commercial reality.
Our manufacturing supply chains do not stop at national borders, and neither should our industrial thinking.
These are precisely the sort of issues where specialist trade associations can make a difference. They have the detailed sector knowledge, international relationships and collective influence to challenge decisions that individual businesses would find almost impossible to influence.
Industrial intelligence: the foundation of effective representation
One of the greatest strengths of a specialist trade association is the depth of knowledge and intelligence it develops about the industry it represents.
Over many years, CBM has built an extensive understanding of the challenges, opportunities and commercial realities facing metalforming businesses.
That knowledge is informed by regular engagement with members, industry data, technical discussions, specialist committees, market intelligence and the sharing of experiences across our membership.
It provides insight into everything from energy costs, raw material availability and international trade to employment legislation, skills shortages, environmental requirements and changing customer demands.
Crucially, this intelligence is not simply collected and stored. It is analysed, shared and used to inform our representations to government.
When CBM challenges a proposed policy, we can draw upon the practical experiences of manufacturers, technical expertise and sector-specific evidence to demonstrate the likely consequences.
This is particularly important when dealing with complex issues such as steel safeguards, carbon border measures and industrial energy policy, where the detail can make the difference between a policy that supports British manufacturing and one that inadvertently damages it.
A general understanding of business is not always sufficient to appreciate these complexities.
Government needs access to detailed industrial intelligence from the sectors directly affected by its decisions.
Specialist trade associations are uniquely positioned to provide it.
The importance of independent representation
My experience at CBM has reinforced the importance of having an independent voice that is prepared to challenge government, whatever its political persuasion.
Our work on steel policy has demonstrated why this matters. We fully support the need for a sustainable domestic steel industry, but that cannot be achieved at the expense of the downstream manufacturers who use steel.
Our members would buy British steel wherever the specification, quality, volume and commercial conditions allow. However, manufacturers cannot be expected to compromise their own competitiveness because government policy has failed to recognise the commercial realities of the supply chain.
Similarly, our work on the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) has highlighted the importance of early engagement.
CBM began raising concerns about the implications of carbon border measures well before they became a major political issue.
Through research, member engagement and direct discussions with HM Treasury and HMRC, we have worked to ensure that the downstream manufacturing sector has a voice in how the policy is developed and implemented.
Our ability to draw upon detailed sector intelligence and the experiences of businesses throughout the supply chain has been central to this work.
The same principle applies across automotive, energy, employment, skills and industrial strategy.
A trade association must be prepared to challenge policy, but it must also offer solutions.
Simply saying no is not enough.
Effective representation requires evidence, expertise, persistence and, above all, an understanding of the businesses affected.
More than lobbying: the commercial value of membership
It would be a mistake to think that the value of trade associations begins and ends with Westminster.
Their role is much broader.
One of the particular advantages of belonging to a specialist association such as CBM is the opportunity to develop commercial relationships with other businesses operating within the same industry.
Our members are not simply companies sharing common concerns. They are potential customers, suppliers, partners and sources of technical expertise.
The combination of SMEs, Tier 1 suppliers and corporate members creates opportunities for businesses of different sizes to engage directly with one another.
For smaller manufacturers in particular, access to larger businesses and established supply chains can be extremely valuable.
Equally, larger organisations benefit from direct relationships with specialist manufacturers whose capabilities, flexibility and innovation are essential to their own competitiveness.
Through networking, industry meetings, events and direct introductions, CBM provides opportunities for members to identify new business, strengthen supply chains and develop relationships that might otherwise be difficult to establish.
This is a practical commercial benefit of membership that should not be underestimated.
There is also considerable value in the transfer of knowledge and expertise.
Members can learn from one another’s experiences, share best practice, understand emerging technologies and identify solutions to common problems.
Whether the subject is productivity, automation, energy efficiency, skills development or regulatory compliance, the ability to exchange knowledge with businesses facing similar challenges is an important competitive advantage.
The more specialist the membership, the more relevant those discussions can become.
In this respect, a trade association is not simply a representative body. It is a business network, a source of industrial intelligence and a platform for collaboration.
Connecting industry, education and government
Trade associations also provide an important connection between education, government and employers.
CBM’s work with Enginuity and the Department for Work and Pensions on addressing the challenges surrounding young people who are not in education, employment or training is one example.
Our support for the First Chance Movement, established by Alan Milburn, is another opportunity to connect the needs of manufacturers with a wider national effort to get more young people into work.
For specialist manufacturing sectors, these relationships are particularly important.
Skills shortages cannot always be addressed through broad national initiatives alone. Different industries require different technical capabilities, training pathways and qualifications.
By working directly with employers, CBM can help ensure that the particular needs of metalforming businesses, especially SMEs, are understood by those developing skills policy.
Across British industry, other trade associations are undertaking similar work, whether in apprenticeships, innovation, exports, sustainability or improving productivity.
This is an increasingly important contribution at a time when government departments are often working in isolation and businesses are left trying to join the dots.
A partnership government cannot afford to ignore
I believe government needs to rethink the way it engages with trade associations.
Too often, consultation is treated as a procedural exercise rather than a genuine opportunity to understand the consequences of policy.
Organisations representing SMEs are not always included early enough, and sometimes not included at all.
It is particularly frustrating when decisions affecting an entire supply chain are taken without proper representation from the businesses operating within it.
Government frequently engages with the largest and most prominent business organisations, and there is undoubtedly value in those relationships.
However, consulting a broad cross-section of British business is not the same as understanding the detailed needs of individual industrial sectors.
The two approaches should complement one another, not compete.
Specialist associations such as CBM can provide the technical understanding, commercial intelligence and direct access to manufacturers that broader organisations may not possess to the same degree.
And when an association represents businesses collectively generating £27 billion in turnover and employing more than 70,000 people, its contribution should not be overlooked simply because its membership is concentrated within one specialist sector.
Indeed, that concentration is precisely what makes its contribution so valuable.
Trade associations should not be regarded simply as another lobbying interest.
They are a source of independent industrial knowledge, a means of understanding complex supply chains and a direct connection to the businesses that government needs to succeed.
If ministers are serious about economic growth and reindustrialisation, they need to recognise that the manufacturing sector is not made up of a handful of household names.
It is an ecosystem of thousands of businesses, many of them SMEs, employing people in communities across the country.
Those businesses need to be heard, not as an afterthought but as an integral part of the decision-making process.
United we are stronger
Of course, trade associations can only be as strong as the commitment of their members.
Membership should not simply be about attending events, receiving updates or calling on the association when a problem arises.
It is about participating, sharing experiences, contributing intelligence, developing commercial relationships and recognising that the challenges facing one business today may affect an entire sector tomorrow.
The more members engage, the stronger the collective voice becomes.
For CBM, the value of that engagement is particularly significant.
Our specialist membership means that information shared by one company can help others facing similar challenges. It can strengthen our lobbying, improve our understanding of emerging issues and create new opportunities for collaboration and business development.
I would encourage businesses, particularly those SMEs that perhaps question the value of belonging to a trade association, to look at the environment in which they are now operating.
The combination of political uncertainty, trade wars, changing regulations and increasing international competition makes going it alone a much riskier proposition.
Belonging to a specialist association provides something that is difficult to achieve independently: a collective industrial voice, access to relevant expertise and intelligence, and connections with other businesses operating within the same supply chain.
The battles ahead will not be won by individual businesses working in isolation.
They require collective representation, informed argument and the determination to make sure that the people making decisions understand the consequences for those expected to deliver them.
Trade associations have a responsibility to step up, but government also has a responsibility to listen.
If we genuinely want to reindustrialise Britain, strengthen our supply chains and create a competitive manufacturing economy, then the voices of the businesses doing the manufacturing must be heard.
And perhaps it is time that government recognised that specialist trade associations are not simply part of the lobbying landscape, but an essential part of the solution.
Finally, as we approach the end of another challenging year, I would like to thank everyone who has supported, contributed to and engaged with our work throughout the year.
I wish all our members, colleagues and friends across the wider manufacturing community a very Merry Christmas and a Happy and Healthy New Year.
I look forward to continuing the conversations and, more importantly, the battles ahead in 2027.